Table of Contents
This article contains affiliate links. If you purchase a product or service through an affiliate link of mine, I may receive a commission or incentive. There is no additional charge for you.
A client of mine looked at her website statistics a little while ago and found something unexpected. Her most visited page wasn’t her homepage or her most popular blog post. It was her error page. Old links had broken, and many of her visitors landed on a page that told them the thing they wanted wasn’t there.
If that happens on your site, the error page is telling you something. And there is a fix for both sides: one for the visitor who lands there, and one for the website that keeps sending them there.
What a 404 is, and what happens when you haven't planned for one
A 404 is what a website sends back when someone asks for a page that doesn’t exist. Maybe they typed the address wrong. Maybe they clicked an old link in an email, a social post, or someone else’s website to a page that used to exist but was moved or deleted. Either way, the server says “404, not found”.
What your visitor sees next depends on whether you planned for it.
If you didn’t, they might get a bare page from your theme with a single line of text. Or a plain browser error that doesn’t even look like your website. Either way, the visitor doesn’t know what to do next. So they do the only thing left. They leave.
And you never hear about it. That person wanted something from you, clicked a link to get it, and quietly went away.
However, you can actually design your 404 page so that people get to a page that makes it clear what they were looking for isn’t there, but you’re here to help them.
What to put on your 404 page
A good 404 page does one job: it catches someone who is lost and gives them a way forward. Which means you want to build it up with the following elements:
A short “something’s off” message, in your own voice. No need for anything fancy or technical. Something like: hey, this page doesn’t exist (anymore), but let’s find you what you came for. Or, as I put it for a client: ‘Oops, this page jumped away’. 🐸
A search bar. If they were looking for something specific, let them search for it right there. The page might still exist; they might just have had the wrong link. A search can help them find it.
Suggestions of where to go. Your most popular posts, your main pages, your contact page. Think about what people usually come to your site for, and put those first.
If you build with Elementor Pro, you can make a 404 template in the Theme Builder, so it matches the rest of your site exactly. A lot of other builders have options like that. But if you don’t, there are also plugins that help you create a 404 page.
Whichever you choose, a good 404 page catches people. But if lots of visitors are landing there, the page isn’t the fix. Something on your site broke, and that’s what needs your attention next.
Hey, you! 😊 Sometimes what we need is someone else’s mind to help us sort through the mess.
When lots of visitors land there, check your 404 log
A few visitors on your 404 page is normal. Someone mistyped, someone followed an ancient link from a forum. But when your error page starts climbing up your statistics, there is almost always a reason.
The most common one is a rebuild. You redesign your website and, along the way, addresses change. Blog posts move from one structure to another. Pages get new, shorter names. Old categories disappear. On your new site, everything works perfectly, because all the internal links point to the new addresses. But every link out there in the world still points to the old ones. Your emails, your social posts, other people’s websites, podcast show notes, Google’s own index. All of those now have nowhere to lead… Which means visitors go to your 404 page.
Instead, you want to make sure that those old addresses have somewhere to go that makes sense.
A lot of SEO plugins have the option to monitor 404s. My favourite is RankMath. In simple mode, the 404 Monitor logs the address someone tried, how often it was tried, and when. Then go through the list and decide, link by link. There are three options.
Redirect it. Real people are using the link, other websites point to it, and there is a good match on your site. Send it there with a permanent (301) redirect. This is where your podcast episodes, renamed pages and moved blog posts go.
Let it go. The content is gone on purpose, and nothing replaces it. Then a 404 is fine, and Google says so too. If you want to be extra clear, a 410 tells search engines the page is gone for good.
Ignore it. A lot of what lands in your log isn’t people at all. Bots and scanners try addresses like wp-login.php, .env or xmlrpc.php on every website they can find, looking for weak spots. You don’t need to redirect those, and you shouldn’t!
I worked on a podcast site with hundreds of episodes where we did exactly this. We had rebuilt the site, and the episode addresses changed. We had already redirected all old links we knew about. But then we found out through the log that there was even another format of links out there that we hadn’t redirected. Which meant 167 old episode links were landing on the 404 page! We matched each old address to its new one and redirected them in bulk.
And please, never redirect every 404 to your homepage. I would never do that. Someone who clicked a link to a specific blog post and lands on your homepage is just as lost as before, only now without the message telling them so. Google may even treat that kind of redirect as an error page in disguise (they call it a soft 404).
If you are planning a rebuild, decide what your addresses will be before you build, and plan the redirects as part of the project. I go into that kind of planning in Before You Touch a Single Page.
You don't have to fix everything
When you open a 404 log for the first time, it can look like a lot. Don’t panic. You don’t need to fix every line in it.
Fix the links real people still use. Let the rest go, ignore the bots, and give everyone who still ends up on your 404 page a nudge in the right direction. That alone is a big step up from a page that says nothing at all!
Setting up a proper 404 page, switching on a log and sorting out the first batch of redirects is a nicely contained job. If you’d rather hand it over, that’s what Tech Hours are for. And if you’re in the middle of a rebuild, or the broken links are a sign the whole site needs rethinking, have a look at how I do Websites.
So, do you know how many of your visitors are landing on your error page right now? 😊


